Genre: Erotic Contemporary Romance Heat Level: 3 Word Count: 66, 000 ISBN: 978-0-3695-0987-1 Editor: Lisa Petrocelli Cover Artist: Jay Aheer

With This Wish by Sydney Scott

Heat Level 3
$4.99
SKU 978-0-3695-0987-1
Stock
Read Description and Excerpt
Wishlist

Create Wishlist

Starlight Lake, 1

Maya’s life hasn’t been easy. After deciding that it could use a little less work and a lot more magic, she makes a wish in the town fountain. That day, Maya meets Jake and falls instantly. One magical night and two pink lines later, Maya is pregnant with his child and no way to contact him.

Jake has always been a man of routine, following the plans he laid out for himself years ago, even when it meant leaving the beautiful woman he loved back at Starlight Lake. Three years later, Jake can’t stop thinking about Maya. When he finally returns to the small town, he finds that his love isn’t the only thing that he left behind.

As the two reconnect, they’ll discover that sometimes wishes do come true, just not in the way you expect them to.

 

Excerpt:

The smell of warm chocolate and sugar draws me to a group of tables at the side of the square, and as I get closer, I can see a group of men and women handing out cups of hot chocolate and napkins filled with frosted sugar cookies. Now that the sun is down, the air has more of a bite to it and my hoodie isn’t doing much to keep the chill out, so a warm beverage sounds like just the ticket. As I approach the front of the line, the smile on my face widens when I get a look at one of the many people standing behind the tables. She’s changed her outfit, but there’s no mistaking the woman from the shop I first visited. Her eyes are bright as she smiles and chats with a small family, handing cookies to the children and hot chocolate to the adults.

While she’s otherwise occupied, I take a moment to get another look at the woman who has dominated my thoughts all evening long. Her hair is down, showcasing the light-colored tresses that fall to her chest in loose waves, her cheeks are rosy from the cold, and her lips are red and full. The sweater dress she’s wearing is only slightly hidden behind a thick scarf and cuts off above the knee. Her ankle boots go to just below, so I only get a small glimpse of skin, but what I can see is slender and fair. To say she’s wildly attractive is not an exaggeration, and I wonder how such a beautiful creature isn’t married already. Of course, she could have a boyfriend, but when I look over and see her eyes catching mine, the widening smile on her face and interested expression tell me she’s single.

“Well, well, well,” she says, her eyes dancing with amusement. The melodic tone of her voices soothes any nerves I might have felt, and I long to hear more of it. “It seems you stuck around for the festival after all.”

My cheeks pull tight as my smile takes over my face. “My plans changed,” I tell her with a shrug of my shoulder, as if it weren’t the first time that has ever happened in my life. My eyes roam over the rows of cups and cookies, looking for some signage for pricing. “So, are the treats for anyone, or is there something special I don’t know about?”

A shadow of sadness crosses over her face, but it’s there and gone so quickly I can’t be sure I didn’t imagine it. “Oh, well, they are for anyone who wants some,” she tells me. Her slender hand reaches out and offers up a cup of hot chocolate and a reindeer-shaped cookie which I take immediately. Our fingers brush slightly as I do, and a warm, tingling sensation travels up my hand, spreading throughout my entire body. It feels as though I am being wrapped in the most comforting hug, and we’re barely touching. “They’re free as an incentive for people to not drink alcohol.” She nods to the Mothers Against Drunk Driving banner and I nod in understanding.

“That’s a great idea,” I say, blowing over the top of the cup to cool the liquid down a bit. “I can’t imagine wanting to drink anything other than a hot beverage in this weather, but I could be in the minority.”

The woman chuckles lightly and shakes her head. “Then I’m in the minority too because I feel exactly the same. Nothing beats hot chocolate on a cold day, except maybe mulled cider at Christmas,” she confesses. She turns away momentarily, smiling wistfully as she hands a cookie over to some people next to me. When she’s facing me again, her teeth are biting into her lower lip, and I try not to think about how much I want to free that lip with my thumb before kissing the sting away. That thought almost has me rearing back. I’m never this instantly attracted to someone. “Can I ask you a question?” Her voice is musical and a welcome break from my own thoughts.

I lean in closer to hear over the din, but it’s also a great excuse to get near her. She follows my lead and our heads are close enough that her warm cinnamon-apple smell wafts toward me. It’s comforting in a way I didn’t know a smell ever could be. It smells like home, only no home I have ever had smelled like apple pie. “Go for it,” I tell her before I completely lose my mind and run my nose along her throat just to get another hit.

She narrows her eyes at me for a second before blowing out a breath. “What’s your name?”

My head tilts back slightly, but only just. I don’t want to be any further from her than I have to. “My name?”

Her head bobs, the golden curtain of her hair moving slightly as it does. “Yeah. This is the second time we’ve run into each other today, and I feel silly not knowing your name. I also don’t like thinking of you as simply ‘that guy’ in my head,” she admits. The fact that she thinks of me at all has a fluttery feeling erupting in my chest, and I feel almost giddy at the foreign sensation.

Pulling myself together, I try to come off a little less crazy than I’m feeling. “Jake,” I tell her extending my hand for a shake. “And you are?”

“Maya,” she tells me, her warm hand slipping into mine. It sends another wave of tingles through me and everything in my body is telling me to hold onto this woman and never let her go. “It’s nice to meet you, Jake.”

“Likewise.” The grip I have on her hand never lightens, and I know enough time has passed that I should probably let it go, but I can’t seem to find the will to do so. There’s not much time left before I must start my drive, but I want whatever time I have left to be spent with Maya. “Say, Maya. How long are you needed here?”

Her eyes sparkle and she smiles coyly. “I can be done right now. That is, if I have a good enough reason to leave.” My brain is already spinning up a million reasons to give her until she decides one is acceptable enough to leave with me.

My eyes flick to the band playing in the center of the square. “Would dancing with me be a good enough reason?” I’m not a big dancer, never have been, but I find that I’m doing all sorts of things outside my comfort zone today. The smile pulling across Maya’s face in response to my question tells me they’ve all been worth it.

“More than good enough,” she confesses. Leaning over to speak to another volunteer for a second, she finishes and steps out from behind the table.

I slam my hot chocolate, ignoring the slight burn as the rich liquid travels down my throat. After tossing the cup and pocketing the cookie, I lead her by the hand to where people are dancing. The band switches to a slower Christmas song I don’t recognize, and I spin Maya around before pulling her into my arms. Her free hand slides up and grips my shoulder while mine rests at her lower back, keeping her as close as possible while still being appropriate for public. As we sway to the light melody, our eyes meet and we stare at one another longingly and let the magic of the evening take over. The world seems to disappear around us. Maya smiles serenely before resting her head on my shoulder, my cheek brushing against the top of her head as I lean mine down to rest on hers. We’re a perfect fit.

As we rock back and forth, I try to memorize everything about the marvelous creature next to me. The way she looks, smells, sounds. All those things are committed to memory for me to pull out and reexamine when I get back to my routine. My heart already aches at the thought of leaving her, but no one uproots their life for one person after a small exchange of words and one dance. Something about Maya has me feeling like all my plans, all my little routines were just a way to lead me to her, but how can that be possible? It’s too good to be true, but I’ll be damned if I don’t embrace this while I have it.

The music stops, but we don’t part from one another. We stay close, our bodies practically merging as we listen to the mayor of the town introduce herself and start the countdown to the lights being turned on. Being with her like this feels like the most natural thing in the world. When the shouting of the crowd gets to one and the lights turn on, Maya looks up at me with the most beautiful expression that I can’t not kiss her. Leaning my head down toward hers, I pause only for a moment to give her time to back away if it’s not what she needs. Instead of doing that, she surprises me by wrapping both arms around my back and leaning up on her tiptoes until her lips meet mine.

It doesn’t take any time for my mind or body to react, and the next thing I know my hands are cupping her face as I lick her bottom lip and dive into her mouth. She opens for me readily, and we explore each other. Our lips are in sync with one another, and our tongues glide against one another in a dance not unlike the one we just shared. It’s slow and sensual with the promise of more, and my heart longs to do nothing but this for the rest of my life. When the band starts playing again, we break apart, our mouths only inches from each other’s, our breath mingling together visibly in the cold night air. Maya’s eyes search mine for a moment, and then she smiles, gripping my hand and interlacing our fingers together. “That was…”

“It was,” I agree. There are no words to describe the feelings I’m having, but they are more potent than anything I’ve ever felt. It’s like there’s a helium balloon in my chest and if she doesn’t keep a hold on me, I just might fly away. My phone buzzes in my pocket, probably a call from my parents wondering if I got in okay, but I ignore it. Denver can wait. I’ll get there eventually, but right now my sole focus is on getting as much time with this woman as I can. My eyes dart around the square, looking for a place we can go and get to know each other a little better, but all the windows are dark. I turn back to Maya. “Is there somewhere we can talk?” I ask. My voice is pleading as I hope she comes up with something. I need more of her, more than I need my next breath. “I suddenly want to know everything there is to know about you.”

Maya’s cheeks turn a deep shade of red, and I know it isn’t from the cold. “Well, most places are closed now,” she starts, biting that lower lip of hers again. “But, we can go back to my apartment if you want.” Her eyes widen and her blush darkens. “To talk, that is.”

A grin spreads across my face. “I’m not expecting more than that, Beautiful.” The endearment came out of nowhere, but I’m not at all surprised by it. Everything about Maya has me acting like a different person, and while the feeling is scary, it’s also king of amazing. My hand spreads out in front of us. “Lead the way.” Maya smiles and steers us through the dispersing crowd over to the sidewalk. It’s hard to make conversation with so many people around, so we just walk in comfortable silence, stealing glances at each other every now and then and smiling like a couple of kids with a crush, though this feels more like love at first sight. My heart soars at being able to spend more time with her tonight, but I can feel the heaviness waiting to set in as soon as I have to go. As we continue on our way, one thought plays on repeat inside my head as I look at the amazing woman next to me. I wish I could keep you.

Series:
/series-starlight-lake/

Product Reviews

Score: 5 out of 5 (based on 12 ratings)
leave a review
5/5
Awesome read
Written by Laura Ann on 4th May 2025

Maya and Carter now own Hodgepodge, a shop for their arts and crafts as well as selling some of the local artisans stuff. Carter is an amazing woodworker. The store opened first by their grandfather and then their parents took over, and now Maya and Carter take care of everything. Although, Maya went to college for Art History, she didn’t complete her degree because her parents passed. Their honorary Aunt, Sue, comes 2 or 3 times a year for a visit and acts as their mom, and she is a successful salesperson. Jake has always had a very regimented life, schedules are pretty much his life’s blood. Until he ends up in Maya’s town. The things that take him out of his comfort zone changes him and he and Maya hook up, but their feelings are engaged. He continues on, to where he will be working with his father and his friend who have run the company for over 25 years. Anton is Billie’s dad and Billie is a riot. She throws Chaos at Jake and he tries to keep her on the straight and narrow. While in Maya’s town, he makes a wish at the Wishing Well, which changes his life and Maya’s forever. I totally loved this book, although, I still want to hit Jake a few times for not going back to visit. I can’t wait to see if anything happens between Carter and Billie. The kids are so cute in this book. I could watch them forever!

5/5
Jake and Maya
Written by Babs on 4th May 2025

A good start to the Starlight Lake series. Jake and Maya's second chance after a one night stand and three years apart. When he comes back into her life there is a surprise he does not know about, their son JJ. A well written story with a very good storyline that held my interest until the end. I want to read the next book. I received a copy of this book via Evernight and am voluntarily leaving a review.

5/5
Do You Believe in Magic?
Written by BLT on 4th May 2025

This is a good start to the Starlight Lake series. This is a wonderful, heart warming, second chance book that is well written that will keep you turning the pages. This is the first book I’ve read by this author and I look forward to reading more books of her books. If you don't believe in magic, you will after reading this book.

5/5
Great start for this new series--author is an amazing storyteller!
Written by Andrea R on 4th May 2025

Hero is focused and driven and rarely changes his plans but when he arrives he makes a split decision that he doesn't think will much matter in the grand scheme of things. Heroine makes a truly uncharacteristic decision when she meets the hero and her life is permanently altered after the unexpected one night stand left unexpected results. I love how this story unfolds with the twists and turns of this love story.

5/5
A Must Read
Written by Danee on 4th May 2025

A wonderful story with an emotional edge. We follow Maya and Jake, he never deviates from his route but makes an exception. He meets Maya there, she and her brother are left with only the wood shop of their parents who were unfortunately killed by a drunk driver. After a while they have a steamy night and she thought things could get better until she wakes up alone the next day and he was gone. He leaves behind not only her but someone else as well. Will they be able to pick up the thread again after years?

5/5
Emotions!!
Written by Wendy L on 4th May 2025

This is the first book in a new series, and this is Jack and Maya’s story. This is a well written story which is an emotional roller coaster, with family, loss, grief, surprises, second chances, and love, which leads to a touching small town romance. I received a free copy of this book via Booksprout and am voluntarily leaving a review.

4/5
Maya and Jake
Written by SheilaAshley3670 on 26th Apr 2024

Jake never detours from his plans until he drives into Starlight Lake and meets Maya. She and her bother have been left with their parents woodworking shop and little else when they were killed by a drunk driver. Meeting Jake and spending a night with him was unlike her and waking up with him gone was probably for the best but there is a surprise he left with Maya and he finds out what is was three years later when he comes back into town.

4/5
Maya and Jake
Written by Lillah C on 26th Apr 2024

With This Wish: book 1 of Starlight Lake is without a doubt a well written book, however I didn’t connect with the story very well.

5/5
Loved it!
Written by Red18 on 26th Apr 2024

This book was romantically sweet with a dash of spice that fit so well with the storyline. I really loved the characters and the plot because they were very real and believable. A magical love at first sight story with a little surprise written in.

4/5
Plans Are Made to be Broken
Written by robbob19 on 26th Apr 2024

Plans Are Made to be Broken Touching story about death, love and loss … and learning how to move on while not being able to let go. I’m usually not a fan of one night stand books but this one is different than the norm. Maya struggles for two years trying to cope with her parents tragic death. Desperately wanting family, she goes to the local holiday lighting event, tosses a coin in the fountain and wishes for a family. Little does she know that wish will come true, but she never dreamed the way it would happen. Jake is a man with a plan… always. Love is the last thing on his mind when he takes a trip break enroute to a new job in Denver. Love at first sight, let alone a one night stand, certainly was not part of the plan… for Jake or Maya. Ahhh, life can be cruel sometimes. Maya wakes up alone with only a sweet goodbye note. But Jake left her with a gift too, in the form of a bundle of joy. Sooo, remember that wish for a family? Nine months later Maya gives birth to little JJ. With no way to locate Jake, Maya is a single mother with her brother, Carter, being little JJ’s male role model. It’s been three long years but Jake can’t forget Maya. It’s time for a road-trip, and boy does he get the surprise of his life. ? OBSERVATIONS ➡️ I wanted to see Jake’s parents meet JJ. ➡️ The couple intimate bedroom scenes are easy to skip without missing anything important in the story. ➡️ For me, it was a slow start but my interest picked up when JJ was born. ➡️ I’m thinking Carter and Billie have a future.

4/5
Plans Are Made to be Broken
Written by robbob19 on 26th Apr 2024

Plans Are Made to be Broken Touching story about death, love and loss … and learning how to move on while not being able to let go. I’m usually not a fan of one night stand books but this one is different than the norm. Maya struggles for two years trying to cope with her parents tragic death. Desperately wanting family, she goes to the local holiday lighting event, tosses a coin in the fountain and wishes for a family. Little does she know that wish will come true, but she never dreamed the way it would happen. Jake is a man with a plan… always. Love is the last thing on his mind when he takes a trip break enroute to a new job in Denver. Love at first sight, let alone a one night stand, certainly was not part of the plan… for Jake or Maya. Ahhh, life can be cruel sometimes. Maya wakes up alone with only a sweet goodbye note. But Jake left her with a gift too, in the form of a bundle of joy. Sooo, remember that wish for a family? Nine months later Maya gives birth to little JJ. With no way to locate Jake, Maya is a single mother with her brother, Carter, being little JJ’s male role model. It’s been three long years but Jake can’t forget Maya. It’s time for a road-trip, and boy does he get the surprise of his life. ? OBSERVATIONS ➡️ I wanted to see Jake’s parents meet JJ. ➡️ The couple intimate bedroom scenes are easy to skip without missing anything important in the story. ➡️ For me, it was a slow start but my interest picked up when JJ was born. ➡️ I’m thinking Carter and Billie have a future.

5/5
Lovely and glimmering
Written by AnnieGYG on 26th Apr 2024

Really nice writing with sprinkles on the top. Filled with love, magic, hurdles to climb, this story takes the reader from disperse to happieness. Would like more from this author.

Similar Items